
This section of the Guide sets out the elements of a model employer policy on workplace accommodation.
1. Statement of commitment
2. Policy objective
3. Policy statement
4. Legal framework
5. To whom does this policy apply?
6. Corporate activities covered by this policy
7. What may be required?
8. Responsibility
9. Undue hardship
10. Procedure
11. Privacy and confidentiality
12. Recourse rights
13. Communication
14. Review
15. Monitoring and reporting
16. Responsibility for interpretation
17. Enquiries
| 7. What may be required? | |
| Question: | Does the policy identify how the range of corporate activities will be examined to ensure the workplace is inclusive and nondiscriminatory? |
| Question: | Does the policy identify the range of issues that may be considered when responding to requests for individual accommodation? |
| Comment: | By identifying the range of issues that can be addressed under the policy, the employer is demonstrating its commitment to dealing with discrimination that may result from the current rules, policies, standards or practices of the organization. Further, the more comprehensive the coverage, the more inclusive the environment and the less likely it is that there will be a need for individual accommodation. The employer is also assisting managers, supervisors and employees to understand their responsibilities and rights in relation to the range of issues that may need to be considered when dealing with a request for accommodation. Federal government departments and agencies should note that the Public Service Employment Regulations have been amended specifying that an employee's probationary period can only commence after an employee has been accommodated. |
| Sample: | [Everyone's Workplace Inc.] will ensure that, before deciding on or engaging in corporate actions, it will analyse these actions so as to identify and resolve potential barriers. Further, it will review all existing policies and procedures to identify and remove discriminatory elements. This may well involve permanent or ongoing changes to facilities, practices, policies and procedures. [Everyone's Workplace Inc.] will ensure that it provides, in a timely and effective way, accommodation specific to an individual's needs. (See PART 4: Individual Accommodation Procedures Guide.) This could include, but is not limited to:
[Everyone's Workplace Inc.] recognizes that the need for accommodation may arise during the employment selection process, at the commencement of employment or at some time after employment has commenced. An employee's probationary period can only commence after an employee has been appropriately accommodated. |
| 9. Undue hardship | |
| Question: | Does the policy commit your organization to considering all options to provide accommodation short of experiencing undue hardship? |
| Question: | Does the policy commit your organization to providing alternative accommodation up to the point of undue hardship, if the specific accommodation requested is considered to involve undue hardship? |
| Comment: | Human rights legislation and case law have established the responsibility of employers to make changes to workplace policies, rules, practices and operations that result in discrimination and provide individual accommodation unless doing so would involve undue hardship. While the question of what constitutes undue hardship varies with the circumstances of employers, the courts have made it clear that employers must expect to experience some hardship in eliminating barriers and providing accommodation. The question tribunals and courts address is whether or not the hardship is undue. The Canadian Human Rights Act provides that undue hardship must be assessed considering "health, safety and cost". The mere fact that some cost, financial or otherwise, will be incurred is insufficient to establish undue hardship. Some of the factors that the courts have considered relevant to an appraisal of what constitutes undue hardship include: disruption of the collective agreement, impact on other employees, interchangeability of work force and facilities, size and financial resources of employer, availability of other positions and external financing, and details of any additional risks or detriments. These considerations should be applied with common sense and flexibility in the context of the factual situation presented in each case. Keep in mind that there is a heavy onus upon employers and service providers to satisfy the courts that they will in fact suffer undue hardship if they are obliged to provide the accommodation requested. The Procedures Guide offers some guidance on how an employer might go about making decisions on this matter. Where an employer concludes that a particular means of providing accommodation will result in undue hardship, it can choose to refuse to implement that particular means. However, the responsibility to provide accommodation still exists. For example, extensive changes to a work schedule to accommodate someone with a medical condition may be considered by the employer to constitute undue hardship, because of the effect the changes would have on the whole operation. Refusing that specific request does not mean that the employer should not attempt to find alternative ways of responding to the request. It is important to note, however, that only alternatives that are going to achieve non-discriminatory access or participation (without imposing undue hardship) are relevant. |
| Sample: | [Everyone's Workplace Inc.] is not required to make changes to workplace policies, rules, practices and operations or provide accommodation that will result in undue hardship. Before refusing to provide accommodation, [Everyone's Workplace Inc.] will ensure that all effective options to accommodate, short of undue hardship, are considered. Where a particular means of accommodation is requested and it has been found that it cannot be met without incurring undue hardship, every effort will be made to provide alternative accommodation up to the point of undue hardship. The accompanying procedure document provides guidance on the issues that may be considered in relation to whether or not the provision of a particular accommodation will result in undue hardship. It also sets out the authority delegated to different management levels to approve specific financial or other allocations for accommodation. |
| Previous Page | Table of Contents | Next Page |